Articles

Main background Main background

Dubai Court Orders Law Firm to Repay Dh1.118 million in Client Funds: Fees Cannot Be Self-Deducted

Dubai Court Orders Law Firm to Repay Dh1.118 million in Client Funds: Fees Cannot Be Self-Deducted
Reviewed by
Mahia Nazeer Legal Associate

Contact Us




    The Dubai Court of First Instance has ordered a law firm to return Dh1,118,871.51 that it collected on behalf of a corporate client and withheld for more than a year. The court held that money a lawyer collects for a client must be treated as a deposit and returned on request, and that a lawyer cannot keep it to recover unpaid fees without following the proper legal procedure.

    The ruling, reported by Gulf News on 10 November 2026, is a practical reminder for any firm or representative who handles execution proceeds or other money belonging to clients. On the facts reported, the decision does not remove a lawyer’s right to be paid. It requires that the right be pursued through recognised court procedures rather than through self-help deduction.

    1. The Dispute: From Cheque Execution to a Withheld Deposit

    A company engaged the law firm to handle cheque execution proceedings over a Dh5.49 million claim. During those proceedings, the debtor deposited Dh1.118 million into the court’s execution account. According to the report, the firm transferred the money to its own bank account in August 2025 and did not hand it over despite repeated demands.

    The company later revoked the firm’s power of attorney and made a formal written demand for repayment in June 2026, before applying to the execution judge. In July 2026, the execution judge ordered the lawyer to return the full amount, either to the court treasury or directly to the company’s bank account. The firm asked for approval to deposit only Dh803,702.24, but the judge directed payment of the full Dh1,118,871.51. The firm’s challenge before the Court of Appeal was rejected in September 2026.

    Separately, the firm’s legal fees were assessed at Dh30,000 in October 2026, and its request to freeze the execution proceeds as security for those fees was rejected. The company then filed a civil claim, with 1 October 2026 reported as the filing date, seeking the refund and compensation.

    2. Preliminary Objections Rejected

    In the civil claim, the firm challenged the company’s legal representation and sought dismissal. The court rejected the objection, finding that valid powers of attorney authorised the company’s representatives to appoint lawyers and take legal action.

    The court also held that the expiry of the company’s trade licence did not mean the company had ceased to exist, entered liquidation or lost its legal representation. For businesses with lapsed licences, this is a useful point: an expired licence does not, by itself, extinguish the company’s standing to recover money owed to it.

    3. Client Money Collected by a Lawyer Is a Deposit

    The court ruled that money collected by a lawyer on behalf of a client must be treated as a deposit and returned when the client asks for it. As reported, the court relied on the UAE Civil Transactions Law, under which an agent must keep the principal informed of the work undertaken, account for the actions taken and return any money or documents held on the principal’s behalf.

    The court also applied a rule of proof drawn from previous judgments: once a client establishes that its agent received money on its behalf, the burden shifts to the agent to prove that the funds were either used for the client’s benefit or returned. The firm could not show that it had returned the Dh1.118 million or deposited it with the court, and the claim succeeded on that basis.

    The new Civil Transactions Law (Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025) took effect on 1 June 2026, replacing the 1985 law. The press report does not identify the specific articles the court relied on, so readers should consult the judgment itself for the precise provisions.

    4. Unpaid Fees Do Not Justify Self-Help Deduction

    The firm argued that its unpaid fees entitled it to keep part of the money. The court rejected the argument, stressing that a lawyer’s right to fees does not override the duty to return clients’ funds. Even a preferential claim for fees does not turn the client’s money into the lawyer’s property or permit automatic deductions.

    The court added that the separate assessment of Dh30,000 in fees did not authorise the firm to deduct that amount from the execution proceeds. The firm’s applications for a judicial set-off and a precautionary attachment had not followed the required legal procedures or included the necessary court fees.

    The firm remains entitled to recover its fees, but it must do so through the proper legal channels. The practical distinction is between a fee claim pursued through the courts and a fee deduction taken unilaterally from money held for the client. Only the former is recognised.

    5. Compensation, Interest and Costs

    The court found that withholding the money despite repeated demands caused the company financial harm, particularly because the firm could have deposited the funds with the court. The company was deprived of the opportunity to use or invest its money for more than a year and had to take further legal action to recover it. The court found a direct link between the firm’s conduct and the company’s losses, establishing grounds for civil liability.

    The Dubai Court of First Instance ordered the firm to:

    • refund Dh1,118,871.51;
    • pay Dh50,000 in compensation, being part of the Dh100,000 the company claimed;
    • pay 5 per cent annual interest on Dh1,118,871.51 from 1 October 2026, the date the lawsuit was filed, until full payment, the court noting that the debt was fixed and did not require further assessment; and
    • bear court fees and expenses, together with Dh1,000 in legal costs.

    6. Practical Takeaways

    For law firms and other representatives who receive money on a client’s behalf, the ruling points to several practical steps:

    • Treat money received for a client as the client’s property, not as security for fees.
    • Account to the client promptly and keep clear records of receipt and transfer.
    • Where a fee dispute exists, return the money or deposit it with the court, and pursue the fee separately through a fee assessment and the applicable court procedures.
    • If seeking a set-off or precautionary attachment, follow the procedural and court-fee requirements. An application that does not do so will not justify retention.

    For clients, the sequence in this case is instructive: revoking the power of attorney, issuing a formal written demand, applying to the execution judge and then filing a civil claim for the refund and compensation. Keeping written records of each demand strengthened the claim for compensation.

    Lawyers practising in the UAE are also regulated by Federal Decree-Law No. 34 of 2022 Regulating the Legal Profession and Legal Consultation Profession, which provides for administrative penalties under Article 86. The report does not indicate that any disciplinary proceedings arose from this case.

    Looking Ahead

    The decision applies a familiar principle: a person who holds another’s money in a representative capacity must account for it and return it. What the ruling adds is a clear statement that unpaid fees are a separate claim to be pursued through proper procedure, not a ground for retaining client funds.

    This is a first-instance decision reported in the press. The report does not say whether an appeal has been filed, and the full judgment has not been published, so the court’s reasoning is summarised as reported. Firms handling execution proceeds should review their internal procedures for receiving, recording and releasing client money, and clients awaiting funds collected on their behalf should act promptly once a legitimate demand has gone unanswered.


    References

    Aghaddir Ali, ‘Dubai Court Orders Law Firm to Return Dh1.1 Million Withheld from Client’ Gulf News (10 November 2026) https://gulfnews.com/uae/dubai/dubai-court-orders-law-firm-to-return-dh11-million-withheld-from-client-1.500741983 accessed 17 November 2026.

    United Arab Emirates Government, ‘The UAE Government Issues a Federal Decree Law Promulgating the Civil Transactions Law’ (UAE Legislation) https://uaelegislation.gov.ae/en/news/the-uae-government-issues-a-federal-decree-law-promulgating-the-civil-transactions-law accessed 17 November 2026.

    Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 Promulgating the Civil Transactions Law https://uaelegislation.gov.ae/en/legislations/4011 accessed 17 November 2026.

    Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2022 Promulgating the Civil Procedure Code https://uaelegislation.gov.ae/en/legislations/1602 accessed 17 November 2026.

    Federal Decree-Law No. 34 of 2022 Regulating the Legal Profession and Legal Consultation Profession https://uaelegislation.gov.ae/en/legislations/1566/download accessed 17 November 2026.


    FAQs

    Can a lawyer deduct unpaid fees from money collected for a client?

    Not automatically. As reported, the Dubai Court of First Instance held that a lawyer’s right to fees does not override the duty to return client funds, and that even a preferential fee claim does not make the client’s money the lawyer’s property. Fees must be recovered through proper legal channels.

    Does the ruling mean a law firm loses its right to be paid?

    No. The firm’s fees were assessed at Dh30,000, and the court confirmed that the firm remains entitled to recover them. What it cannot do is deduct them unilaterally from the execution proceeds or retain the money without following the required procedure, including payment of the relevant court fees for any set-off or precautionary attachment.

    What can a client do if its funds are withheld by its lawyer?

    In this case, the company revoked the power of attorney, sent a formal written demand and applied to the execution judge, who ordered the full amount returned. It then filed a civil claim and obtained a refund, compensation of Dh50,000 and 5 per cent annual interest. Each case depends on its own facts, and legal advice should be taken before choosing a course of action.

    Can a company with an expired trade licence still recover its money in court?

    According to the report, the court held that the expiry of a trade licence does not by itself mean the company has ceased to exist, entered liquidation or lost its legal representation.

    Contact Us




      Call Us Now

      Schedule a free consultation for all your legal challenges

      +971 04 294 3940
      Top